Rotolo's Pizza

In Business Since 1974

3.91 out of 5

Based on 33 reviews

Rate it at YellowPages.com
 

1749 W 5th Ave

Columbus, OH43212

Get Directions

(614) 488-7934

Web Site

Payment Methods

AMEX, DISCOVER, MASTER CARD, VISA

Visit Our Website For A Location Near You

Products and Services

Veggie Pizza,Spaghetti Sauce,Pineapple,Pepperoni,Papa Rotolo's Chef Salad,Onion,Mushrooms,Meat Sauce,Mama Rotolo's Tossed Salad,Italian Sausage,Green Peppers,Fresh Tomatoes,Fresh Garlic

Search Columbus Yellow Pages

Category or Business Name
City, ZIP Code, Address, or Landmark

Reviews

Review it at YellowPages.com

R.I.P. Rotolo's

Posted byMatthew4694on 8/9/2009

You can officially add Rotolo's Pizza to the ever-expanding list of food institutions in Columbus that have turned on their loyal customers and sold us down the corporate-restaurant river. Like Donato's Pizza, Bob Evans Restaurants and W.G. Grinders before them, Rotolo's has decided that more locations with higher prices, lower quality and minimal service are the best way to reward customers who helped drive their success for over 30 years. I have been going to Rotolo's for the last 20 years and my most recent visit has confirmed my worst fears. The friendly service, homemade taste, and commitment to quality have been replaced with a corporate identity, a clueless, non-family member staff, and higher priced - inferior quality pizza. It is a sad day along West Fifth Avenue, indeed, but should I really be surprised anymore? Some people just can't wait to sell out these days - just ask Jim Grote. I attempted to complain at the company's corporate website, but strangely, no e-mail address is available to contact ownership or management. I guess the Rotolo family is now too busy to be bothered with things like loyalty and customer satisfaction...R.I.P. Rotolo's - We'll miss you!

Fabulous pizza!

Posted bynafnalaon 2/11/2009

We always order from the Worthington location and have never been disappointed. Wonderful pizza every time! Always fresh ingredients and always ready or delivered on time. One of the top two pizza joints in Columbus!

Nothing Special

Posted bynailzuzon 1/27/2009

The pasta, and roll were just average. The pizza itself was ok. It was very raw tasting in the middle. They almost put too much sauce so that the pizza doesn't cook properly. On the very first slice literally all the cheese and toppings fell off. They do however give you a decent amount to feed at least 3.

Best Baked rigatoni!!!!

Posted bybrowniion 6/22/2008

Try the baked rigatoni...they bake that great pizza cheese thru out ... I heard about it word of mouth It reminds me of the baked ziti I use to get in New York!!!!!!! Yummy Yummy

Terrible Italian food

Posted byBagel0214on 5/26/2008

This is by far the worst meal I've had in at least a year. I ordered take-out. Although it was not busy, it took them 30 minutes to get me my order after being told it would only take five. I ordered the spaghetti which was undercooked and slathered in the worst sauce I've ever tasted. A note: heavy salt does not make up for lack in taste! The mushrooms in the sauce were chewy and tasteless. The order came with two rolls, one of which was so stale I couldn't eat it!